Kevin Kent 0 - 1 Dave Regis
This was a good scrap; White was always one move short of landing the final blow and Black
wriggles out into a better endgame. This is I guess how you are supposed to play with Black;
easier in correspondence than OTB! It also confirms my prejudices about the line: in my games
Black scored 2/3 in the gambit accepted!
This is a well-known position, and both sides have tried several alternatives. I was heading
for a position which Harding assesses as =+ but White is by no means obliged to comply.
9.Qh4 Nb6
[9...c5 looks the only realistic alternative here.]
10.Bb3 a5 11.a4 Nbd5
This is the first CRITICAL POSITION. White has an apparent opportunity to win
back the Pawn, but Harding thinks this gives Black slightly the better position.
12.Nxd5 Nxd5 13.Bxd5 (13.c4) 13...Qxd5 14.Qxe7 Qc6 (14...Bxd4+ 15.Nxd4 Qxd4+ 16.Be3 Qd7; 14...Qd7) 15.c3 Be6 16.Bf4 Rac8 17.Ne5 Qd5 = Lane, =+ Harding
I hoped White would try and win the e-Pawn, but instead he goes for a slow build-up in the
familiar manner. All the books give only 12. Nxd5, but White actually has lots of alternatives:
(12.Bg5; 12.Bh6; 12.Ne5 Be6 13.Bh6 c6; 12.h3; 12.Ng5 h6)
12.h3
An interesting move, the motivation of which it is worth pondering. Black often has trouble
developing the Bishop on c8, and in the BDG it is often useful to send this Queen's-side piece
out to g4 and exchange it for the dangerous Knight on f3.
I probably wouldn't have gone for ...Bg4: I don't really approve of giving up the two Bishops
like this and the offer to bring the Rf1 into play on f3 also seems unnecessarily helpful.
13...Nxc3
Black has many alternatives here but this looked clearest.
14.bxc3
[14.Ng5 Ne2+ 15.Kh1 Qxd4]
Another CRITICAL POSITION: White has a straightforward plan of Ng5, Bxg7,
Rxf6 and Qxh7 against routine tries by Black. So Black must both avoid this idea and make sure
nothing worse awaits him.
14...Nh5
It was hard to see much else. I looked at a long forcing line here which White played straight
down the middle of. Black can and should have confidence in the position to face attacks like
this, look them in the eye, and find the way to safety. Neither hope nor fear are friends to the
chess player, only judgement and analysis!
15.Bxg7
With hindsight White should have preferred:
[15.Bg5 or; 15.Be3, when it's still a fight]
15...Kxg7 16.Ng5
[16.g4 Nf6 17.Ng5 h6 18.Nxf7 Rxf7 19.Bxf7 g5 20.Qg3 Kxf7 when Black might make something out of
the material imbalance. 21.Rab1]
16...e6
provocative! - but importantly pins the Knight to the Queen
18...Bxe6 19.Qxd8 Raxd8 20.Bxe6 Ng3! 21.Rf3 Ne2+ 22.Kf2 Nxc3 23.Rxc3
[23.Bb3 Ne4+ 24.Ke3 Ng5 (24...f5 25.gxf5 gxf5 26.Rg1+ Kf6 27.Rgf1 Nd6 28.c4 Rde8+ 29.Kd3)
25.Rg3 Rfe8+ 26.Kd3 Ne4 27.Rf3 Nc5+ 28.Kc4 Nxb3 29.Rxb3 is rather like the game continuation in
the end!]
23...fxe6+
... and Black has wangled his extra pawn back. If I had been frightened of the attack at move
14-18 I might have had to back out of the whole line, but I couldn't see a way through, and
wanted to prove the point. This is easier in correspondence than OTB, I admit, but you must have
this attitude. Even if you are wrong and are proved wrong about the variations, your attitude is
still right.
26...Rxe5+ 27.Kd4 Rd5+ 28.Kc4??
throwing away another Pawn because of the loose Rb1. White seemed to lose heart here but some of
the Rook endgames could have been awkward for Black.
[28.Ke4! and Black has to decide if he is going to go passive or try for activity. Although the
books say in general you should go for activity I think uncoiling from a stonewall is Black's
best hope here. 28...Re8+ 29.Kf3 Re7 30.Rcb3 Rdd7 Now Black can transfer the King to c8 and get
a Rook free to harass White's loose Pawns.]
28...Rf4+ 29.Kb3 Rb4+
[29...b5 30.Rxc6 (30.axb5 cxb5) 30...Rxa4 31.Re1 looked less in control]
30.Ka2 Rxa4+ 31.Kb2 Rb4+ 32.Ka2
[32.Rb3; 32.Kc1]
32...Rdb5
forcing an exchange and on Black's terms.
33.Rxb4
[33.Rd1 Ra4+ 34.Ra3 Rxa3+ 35.Kxa3 Kf6]
33...Rxb4 34.Rd3
[34.Rc5 Rb5 35.Rc4 Kf6]
34...Kf6
Just in time. The Queen's-side Pawns are all little monsters; White cannot stop them without
bringing the Rook back, and if he brings the Rook back, the Black King will nibble the King's-side
Pawns.